Paying off non-deductible debt saves you interest without paying tax on that saving. Compare what happens over one year when you use the same money to pay down debt or invest.
$
Amount to repay or invest
%
Annual interest rate
%
Expected annual return before tax
%
Include Medicare levy
Option 1 – Pay down debt
$100
After-tax return on debt payment (0% tax)
Option 2 – Invest instead
$68
After-tax return on investment (32% tax)
Paying down debt leaves you $32 better off.
To match the debt repayment, an investment would need to earn 14.71% before tax.
And that return is guaranteed. Investment returns are not guaranteed. They can fall in value and take years to recover.
This is a simplified annual comparison. It assumes the amount repaid does not exceed the outstanding debt, debt interest is not tax-deductible, the interest saving applies for a full year, and the investment return is fully taxable at your marginal rate in that year. It excludes capital gains tax discounts, franking credits, tax deferral, fees and investment risk. Actual investment outcomes may differ. This is general information, not personal financial advice.